I Got a Demand Letter. Should I Ignore It?

Sometimes, but never by default. Some demand letters are mass mailed and nobody follows up. Others are the last step before a lawsuit. You cannot tell which one you have from the tone of the letter. Staying silent can be the right strategy, but it should be a decision and not avoidance.

I am Natalie Sulimani, a New York attorney with more than 20 years in intellectual property and business law. I evaluate and respond to demand letters for small businesses: copyright claims, trademark cease and desist letters, website privacy claims, and contract disputes.

What a demand letter is

A demand letter is a letter from a lawyer or a company saying you owe money or must stop doing something. It is not a lawsuit. No court is involved yet.

The deadline in the letter was set by the sender. It is not a court deadline. Missing it does not create a judgment against you. It may be the point where the sender decides whether to sue.

When ignoring a demand letter can work

The sender works in volume. Some firms send the same letter to hundreds of businesses and pursue only the ones that answer.

The claim is weak. You had a license, the facts in the letter are wrong, or the law it cites does not fit what you did.

Suing you costs more than the demand. A sender asking for a few thousand dollars has to weigh that against the cost of filing and litigating a case.

I have seen demand letters go quiet with no response at all.

When ignoring a demand letter is a mistake

The sender files lawsuits. Court records show whether this sender follows through. Some do, regularly.

The letter comes with evidence. Screenshots, registration numbers, or a draft complaint mean someone has already done the work to sue.

The law allows more than actual damages. Some claims, including many copyright claims, can carry statutory damages and attorney’s fees. That changes the math on a small demand.

You have insurance. Your business policy may cover the claim, and most policies require prompt notice. Sitting on the letter can cost you the coverage.

The conduct is still going on. Continuing after you have been put on notice can be used to argue the violation was willful.

What to do in the first week

  1. Do not call or email the sender. What you say can be used against you.
  2. Save a copy of everything before you change anything: the post, the page, the files, the emails.
  3. Find your paperwork: licenses, contracts, receipts, platform terms.
  4. Read your insurance policy for claim notice requirements.
  5. Have a lawyer read the letter before the deadline in it.

Paying is not the only alternative to ignoring

The number in the letter is an opening ask. It is not what the claim is worth.

Between paying in full and saying nothing, there is a short response that states your defense, a negotiated lower number, and deliberate silence after a lawyer has sized up the risk.

Which one fits depends on who sent the letter and what they can prove. That takes reading the letter, not guessing.

Send me the letter.

Common questions

Is a demand letter a lawsuit?

No. A lawsuit starts when a complaint is filed in court and served on you. A demand letter comes before that, and many never lead to one.

Do I have to respond by the deadline in the letter?

You have no legal obligation to respond. The deadline is the sender’s. The risk of letting it pass is that the sender sues.

Can I respond to a demand letter myself?

You can, but anything you write can be treated as an admission. People explaining themselves in a reply often hand the sender the facts it was missing.

Should I take down the content the letter complains about?

Often yes, after you save a copy. Leaving it up after you have been put on notice can make the claim worse.

What should I send a lawyer?

The letter and everything attached to it, the date you received it, and any license or contract that covers what the letter complains about. Email them to hello@sulimanilawfirm.com.

Leave a Comment